The closure is a pretty abrupt end to a concept that very quickly became a huge success. It opened in 2025 as a venture by Kevin Smith and Polly Yakovich (the team behind the very successful Loyal Heights butcher shop Beast & Cleaver) and was named Seattle Met's Restaurant of the Year just months after opening. It also earned a James Beard Award semifinalist spot in the Best New Restaurant category.
"The Reason is Simple Math"
Despite the plaudits and the loyal following it has attracted through its excellent range of Scotch eggs, sausage rolls and Sunday roasts, the owners have had to admit the sheer financial reality of running a small restaurant in today's economy.
In a very candid post on Instagram, the owners have laid it out: "The reason is simple math. Labor and food costs have got to the point where a small restaurant can't charge a fair price and come anywhere near breaking even."
The team went to great lengths to make the traditional restaurant model work. They reduced the menu, cut labor by over 30%, and saw walk-ins and bookings up by nearly 60%. Still, that wasn't enough to make the numbers work.
While they acknowledged that they could easily cut costs by sourcing meat from large commodity producers, they firmly refused to compromise their ethical sourcing standards. "It would mean abandoning our principles, as well as the farmers and ranchers who raise meat the right way. We won't do that," the owners explained.